Menu
Your Own Law Firm
  • START HERE
  • Niche Marketing Roadmap
  • Create a Blog in 4 Minutes!
  • Create a Website in 15 Minutes!
  • Aaron Morris
  • Starting Your Own Law Firm
  • Articles
Your Own Law Firm

Don’t Be That Attorney – The Uncommitted Extortionist

Posted on August 21, 2020January 14, 2023 by Aaron Morris

Don't be that attorney
I see this a lot in the wrongful termination context, and I even warn callers, who are seeking to have their case handled on a contingency basis, that they will likely encounter this type of attorney if they make enough calls. I call these attorneys “Uncommitted Extortionists.” The Uncommitted Extortionist is an attorney who will take any case on a contingency, hoping that he can make a quick score, but knowing that he will kick the client to the curb if he can’t. They are usually pretty easy to spot, because they take cases you’d have to be crazy to take.

In today’s example, we represent a business client who is suing for Internet defamation. The defendant in this case has engaged in a form of Internet defamation that has become all the rage in Europe, and is now spreading to our shores. The defamer posts a really bad, false review about a business. Often the review will be about a restaurant, and the defamer will falsely claim that he got food poisoning from the food, and noticed cockroaches everywhere as he was leaving the restaurant. Not that unusual even here in America, but most often they are published by an anonymous competitor, hoping to drive business away from the victim, or from someone with a beef with the business, such as a terminated employee.

The European twist is that the defamer makes the comments in order to extort money from the business. After the review appears, the defamer contacts the business and offers to take it down for a set price. A modern-day protection racket. In some particularly brazen cases I have read about, the extortionist confronts the business owner while still sitting at the table. He calls the owner over, shows him the review, and says, “comp my meal or I hit send.”

So, back to our case. The defendant had been terminated from the business some years earlier, but seeing that our client’s business was doing very well, the defendant posted scathing reviews on multiple websites, falsely claiming that he had a bad experience with our client, and then offered to take them down in exchange for money. We responded by suing him for defamation, and I was soon contacted by his attorney. In the worst case of posturing I have ever seen, the attorney claimed that not only was he going to defeat our defamation lawsuit by proving that the statements were true, he was going to cross-complain for damages arising from the termination, claiming that in reality his client had been an owner, and was now entitled to a share in the business. Never mind that the defendant had been terminated ten years earlier, and that even if the allegations were true, the statute of limitations had long since passed. He demanded $50,000 to forgo pursuing his lapsed action, and for that payment, his client would take down the defamatory posts. We politely declined his offer. I guess he hasn’t been keeping up with what is happening to Michael Avenatti.

True to his word, along with his answer came a cross-complaint, not suing for the alleged ownership interest, but instead suing my client for abuse of process for suing his client – a clear SLAPP. I responded to the cross-complaint with an anti-SLAPP motion, and that generated another call from the attorney. His efforts for a quick settlement thwarted, he was calling to tell me he was subbing out of the case.

Hence the name, Uncommitted Extortionist. The attorney had no problem attempting to use the legal process to extort money based on a bogus claim, and he was even willing to invest the time to draft a (really bad) cross-complaint, but that was as far as he was willing to go. The effort having failed, he was unwilling to spend any more time on the extortion attempt. With no shame, he set the client up for an anti-SLAPP motion, and then abandoned him before he had to deal with it.

Don’t be that attorney. The joy of having a big, fat pipeline of business coming into your practice is that you can be very selective about the cases you take. You will never be tempted to pull an Avenatti.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Contact Aaron Morris

Aaron Morris
Morris & Stone, LLP
11 Orchard Road, Suite 106
Lake Forest, CA 92630
(714) 954-0700
Email Aaron Morris

Find this information useful or entertaining?

Buy me a coffeeBuy me a coffee

Search YourOwnLawFirm.com

#1 Law Firm Marketing Book on Amazon:

Just $4.99, or get a copy
FREE on Kindle Unlimited!

Starting Your Own Law Firm Series

  • Starting Your Own Law Firm
  • Starting Your Own Law Firm – Should I Really Go “Solo”?
  • Starting Your Own law Firm – Choosing Your Office Space
  • Starting Your Own Law Firm – Equipping Your Office
  • Number 1 Rule for a Satisfying Law Practice
  • Adding Profit by Shedding Preconceived Notions
  • Six Rules for 100% Caller to Client Lead Conversion
  • How to Use Flat Fees for a Profitable Practice
  • How to Market Your Law Firm With a Podcast

Law Firm Marketing Series

  • Niche Marketing Roadmap
  • How to Pick a Niche Practice Area
  • Creating Your Niche Website
    • Create a Blog in 4 Minutes!
    • Create a Website in 15 Minutes!
  • How to Create Epic Content for Your Blog
  • Using Content Marketing to Show Off Your Expertise
  • How a Niche Site Can Add $100,000 to Bottom Line
  • Another Benefit of Content Based Marketing
  • How to Market Your Law Firm With a Podcast
  • 6 Rules for 100% Caller to Client Conversion

Gotta Love Those Travel Points

Recent Wisdom

  • buy me a coffee tip jarThe Entertaining Use of “Buy Me A Coffee”
  • Dealing with clients who are convinced, “They are up to something.”
  • Using the HP e-Print Feature at Your Law Office
  • EfficiencyOrganize Your Chrome Bookmarks to Save Time
  • proofreading documentsProofreading Documents by Having Them Read to You — Natural Reader Review
  • charge for consultationShould You Charge for Consultations?

NOTICE 1 — Affiliate Links

I provide affiliate links in this website that pay me a few shekels if you click through and buy the product. However, in all cases these were products that I use or have thoroughly researched, and would recommend regardless of the affiliate program. Also, I seek out or arrange the best deals for you, so buying the product or service through my affiliate link will often save you money; a clear win-win. If you do purchase through my affiliate link, thank you so much for your support!

NOTICE 2 — NOT LEGAL ADVICE

NOTICE PURSUANT TO BUSINESS & PROFESSIONS CODE SECTION 6158.3: This website is directed to lawyers and the practice of law, and is not directed to potential clients. To the extent the author tells a war story, the outcome of any case will depend on the facts specific to that case. Nothing contained in any portion of this web site should be taken as a representation of how your particular case would be concluded, or even that a case with similar facts will have a similar result. The result of any case discussed herein was dependent on the facts of that case, and the results will differ if based on different facts.

This site seeks to present information in a hopefully entertaining manner. Hyperbolic language should not be taken literally. For example, if the author refers to himself as the “Sultan of SLAPP” or the “Pharaoh of Free Speech,” it should not be assumed that he is actually a Sultan or a Pharaoh.

Factual summaries are entirely accurate in the sense of establishing the legal scenario, but are changed as necessary to protect the privacy of the clients.

Blogroll

  • Aaron Morris
  • Best Defamation Attorney
  • California SLAPP Law
  • Internet Defamation
  • Morris & Stone
  • Practice of Law Blog
  • What is Defamation?
©2023 Your Own Law Firm | WordPress Theme by Superb Themes