Menu
Your Own Law Firm
  • START HERE
  • Niche Marketing Roadmap
  • Create a Blog in 4 Minutes!
  • Create a Website in 15 Minutes!
  • Aaron Morris
  • Starting Your Own Law Firm
  • Articles
Your Own Law Firm

A New Way to (Possibly) Add to Your Bottom Line — Write A Bonus Into Your Fee Agreement

Posted on April 3, 2012March 16, 2022 by Aaron Morris

Fee Agreements for Bonuses

I had nothing to do with this case, but an attorney friend of mine alerted me to this very interesting issue arising from an attorney fee application.

Here is the scenario. A party won a breach of contract action and was entitled to attorney fees under the contract in question. As you are no doubt aware, the normal mechanism to calculate reasonable attorney fees is by way of the lodestar method – multiplying the reasonable number of hours spent on the case times the hourly rate, which must be in line with what other similarly situated attorneys charge.

But there are a number of variables. In some instances, if the case was particularly challenging, a multiplier is permitted. Also, if the case was taken on a contingency basis, courts have held that can be an appropriate method for determining the fees. For example, keeping the numbers simple, if a $300 an hour attorney took a case on a 40% contingency, and spent 100 hours on the case to win $100,000, then his hourly fees would be $30,000 but his contingency fee would be $40,000. Cases have held that the a $40,000 fee award is appropriate since that is the real cost to the client and because we must encourage attorneys to take contingency cases since plaintiffs might not otherwise be able to afford counsel.

So back to our scenario. The attorney was representing the client at a rate of, say, $400 per hour. The client could not keep up with the bills, so the attorney agreed to reduce his rate to $200 per hour, with the understanding that if he prevailed in the action, and obtained a verdict above a certain amount, he would get a $100,000 bonus. He won, he achieved the milestone, so in his motion for attorney fees, he sought the $100,000 bonus from the other side.

He argued that the bonus was no different than a contingency fee, and he should be able to obtain it because of the risk involved. Like an attorney handling a matter on a contingency basis, he had made the action affordable to the client by way of this bonus arrangement, and in that manner had made representation available to a client who might not have otherwise been able to afford counsel.

Bonus-Attorney-Fee-ArrangementConceptually the argument is not too far off the beam, but it raises a possibility that causes me great concern. What would keep attorneys from adding bonus provisions to all of their agreements? Indeed, if such fees were permitted, the situation would soon become standard even at the attorney’s full hourly rate. “I charge $450 per hour, but I only take cases where there is a chance of also recovering a significant bonus, so if you won’t agree to a $100,000 bonus, I can’t represent you.” It’s not hard to imagine that some attorneys would use this as a simple method by which to give themselves a big payday at the expense of the opposition, without increasing the fees to their own client.

In this case, the motion failed to recover the bonus, with the judge deciding that the lodestar method was appropriate, and that the bonus would amount to an unearned multiplier. But interestingly, he did consider it and had he found that the case was appropriate for a multiplier, he might have allowed the bonus. So, I throw it out there as something to keep in the back of your mind, should the appropriate circumstance ever arise where you must cut your fee in order to keep representing the client, but want to offset the risk of doing so. So long as you are honest and ethical with its application, I don’t see any downside to this approach.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Contact Aaron Morris

Aaron Morris
Morris & Stone, LLP
11 Orchard Road, Suite 106
Lake Forest, CA 92630
(714) 954-0700
Email Aaron Morris

Find this information useful or entertaining?

Buy me a coffeeBuy me a coffee

Search YourOwnLawFirm.com

#1 Law Firm Marketing Book on Amazon:

Just $4.99, or get a copy
FREE on Kindle Unlimited!

Starting Your Own Law Firm Series

  • Starting Your Own Law Firm
  • Starting Your Own Law Firm – Should I Really Go “Solo”?
  • Starting Your Own law Firm – Choosing Your Office Space
  • Starting Your Own Law Firm – Equipping Your Office
  • Number 1 Rule for a Satisfying Law Practice
  • Adding Profit by Shedding Preconceived Notions
  • Six Rules for 100% Caller to Client Lead Conversion
  • How to Use Flat Fees for a Profitable Practice
  • How to Market Your Law Firm With a Podcast

Law Firm Marketing Series

  • Niche Marketing Roadmap
  • How to Pick a Niche Practice Area
  • Creating Your Niche Website
    • Create a Blog in 4 Minutes!
    • Create a Website in 15 Minutes!
  • How to Create Epic Content for Your Blog
  • Using Content Marketing to Show Off Your Expertise
  • How a Niche Site Can Add $100,000 to Bottom Line
  • Another Benefit of Content Based Marketing
  • How to Market Your Law Firm With a Podcast
  • 6 Rules for 100% Caller to Client Conversion

Gotta Love Those Travel Points

Recent Wisdom

  • buy me a coffee tip jarThe Entertaining Use of “Buy Me A Coffee”
  • Dealing with clients who are convinced, “They are up to something.”
  • Using the HP e-Print Feature at Your Law Office
  • EfficiencyOrganize Your Chrome Bookmarks to Save Time
  • proofreading documentsProofreading Documents by Having Them Read to You — Natural Reader Review
  • charge for consultationShould You Charge for Consultations?

NOTICE 1 — Affiliate Links

I provide affiliate links in this website that pay me a few shekels if you click through and buy the product. However, in all cases these were products that I use or have thoroughly researched, and would recommend regardless of the affiliate program. Also, I seek out or arrange the best deals for you, so buying the product or service through my affiliate link will often save you money; a clear win-win. If you do purchase through my affiliate link, thank you so much for your support!

NOTICE 2 — NOT LEGAL ADVICE

NOTICE PURSUANT TO BUSINESS & PROFESSIONS CODE SECTION 6158.3: This website is directed to lawyers and the practice of law, and is not directed to potential clients. To the extent the author tells a war story, the outcome of any case will depend on the facts specific to that case. Nothing contained in any portion of this web site should be taken as a representation of how your particular case would be concluded, or even that a case with similar facts will have a similar result. The result of any case discussed herein was dependent on the facts of that case, and the results will differ if based on different facts.

This site seeks to present information in a hopefully entertaining manner. Hyperbolic language should not be taken literally. For example, if the author refers to himself as the “Sultan of SLAPP” or the “Pharaoh of Free Speech,” it should not be assumed that he is actually a Sultan or a Pharaoh.

Factual summaries are entirely accurate in the sense of establishing the legal scenario, but are changed as necessary to protect the privacy of the clients.

Blogroll

  • Aaron Morris
  • Best Defamation Attorney
  • California SLAPP Law
  • Internet Defamation
  • Morris & Stone
  • Practice of Law Blog
  • What is Defamation?
©2023 Your Own Law Firm | WordPress Theme by Superb Themes